When an archaeological excavation took place in 1994 at The Rocks, Sydney’s historic precinct, thousands of people came to watch, many volunteered to dig, and for months ‘The Big Dig’ became a popular tourist attraction. For 15 years afterwards the site remained closed to the public while Sydney Harbour Foreshore Authority, the statutory body which manages The Rocks, determined how it could conserve, innovatively interpret, and encourage public access to the site. In 2006 Youth Hostels Australia (YHA) won the tender to develop the site, and in December 2009 Sydney Harbour YHA, the largest archaeological urban development ever completed in Australia, opened its doors to visitors. YHA’s corporate mission — to provide educational and personal development opportunities for young people — was a perfect fit with the government’s plan to revitalise The Rocks by attracting more children and young adults to the historic precinct. Since the education programmes began at The Big Dig Archaeology Education Centre in 2010, 34,000 school students have participated in learning activities that focus on the history of Australia’s first European settlement. This case study demonstrates how archaeology is used as pedagogy at The Big Dig to facilitate learning in an historic environment.